Apartment Disputes in Ireland: The MUD Act, the Circuit Court and Mediation Conferences

In one sentence: The Circuit Court has exclusive jurisdiction over applications under section 24 of the MUD Act. They cannot be made to the High Court (s 26).

Last reviewed · Primary source: Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011 (ss 24-28), Irish Statute Book · all sources

Updated · 5 min read

Most disagreements between apartment owners and their owners’ management company (OMC) are settled with a letter or at a general meeting. When they are not, the Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011 provides a specific court route. This guide explains who can use it, what the court can order and how mediation fits in. For the basics, see our guide to OMCs and the MUD Act.

What the court can deal with

Under section 24, an application can be made to enforce any right or obligation under the MUD Act or any rule of law relating to the development, or for an order on any matter the Act says can be brought this way. Typical examples include an OMC failing to hold an AGM or provide the annual report, disputes about the service charge process, or the enforcement of house rules. Our guides to service charges and house rules explain those obligations.

Who can apply

Section 25 lists who can apply, or appear and be heard:

  • the OMC;
  • any member of the OMC, which in practice means unit owners;
  • a trustee or personal representative of a member;
  • the developer;
  • with the court’s permission, any other person the court sees fit.

Tenants are not on the list, so a tenant with a problem usually needs to go through their landlord or ask the court for permission.

Which court

The Circuit Court has exclusive jurisdiction over section 24 applications, and they cannot be made to the High Court (s 26). The case is heard by the judge of the circuit where the development is located.

Mediation conferences

The application must state whether mediation or another dispute resolution process has been attempted (s 24(2)). The court, on its own motion or at a party’s request, can direct the parties at any stage to meet and try to settle. This is called a mediation conference (s 27). The parties must comply with the direction. The chairperson is agreed by the parties or, failing agreement, appointed by the court, and must then be a practising barrister or solicitor of at least 5 years’ standing or a nominee of a body prescribed by the Minister (s 27(4)). Notes and communications at the conference are confidential and cannot be used in evidence (s 27(5)). The chairperson reports to the court, and if a party ignored the direction or was substantially to blame for no settlement being reached, the court can order that party to pay costs incurred after the direction (s 28).

In practice, it is worth trying mediation before you apply, because you will have to tell the court whether you did.

What the court can order

If the court finds a right has been infringed or an obligation not met, it must make the remedial order it considers appropriate to enforce the right or obligation (s 24(3)). In other cases it can make an order that is just and equitable for the effective running of the OMC and the quiet and peaceful occupation of the common areas (s 24(4)). Orders can include amending the OMC’s legal documentation (s 24(5)).

Before you go to court

  • Write to the OMC directors setting out the problem, the section of the Act involved, and what you want.
  • Raise it at the AGM or ask for an item on the agenda.
  • Propose mediation in writing and keep a copy.
  • Get legal advice on costs before you file.

What this means for owners and residents

  • Keep records: notices, the annual report, budgets and correspondence.
  • Know the obligations the Act puts on the OMC, such as annual meetings and itemised service charge estimates.
  • Consider joining with other owners. Members can each apply, but a joint approach is often more persuasive.

Which court hears MUD Act disputes?

The Circuit Court, which has exclusive jurisdiction over applications under section 24. They cannot be made to the High Court.

Who can apply to the court under the MUD Act?

The OMC, any member, a trustee or personal representative of a member, the developer and, with permission, anyone else the court sees fit.

Do I have to try mediation first?

The Act does not strictly require it, but your application must say whether mediation was attempted, and the court can direct a mediation conference at any stage.

What orders can the court make?

Any remedial order it considers appropriate to enforce a right or obligation, including amending the OMC’s legal documents.

This guide explains the law in general terms for owners and residents. It is not legal advice. Your development’s own documents may add rules, and laws change, so check the linked sources or ask a local lawyer before you act. How we check facts: Editorial Standards.

Sources

  1. Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011 (ss 24-28), Irish Statute Book (irishstatutebook.ie)
  2. Multi-Unit Developments Act 2011, revised (consolidated) text, Law Reform Commission (revisedacts.lawreform.ie)

Related guides

About the author

HOA Strata News Editorial Team

We write plain-English guides for owners, boards and managers in HOAs, condos, strata schemes and co-ops. Every figure is checked against a primary source. Spotted an error? Tell us, and read our Editorial Standards.